Six bottles of olive oil: generous or excessive?
The Everyday EVOO Gifting Set from Kosterina comes with six bottles of Everyday Extra Virgin Olive Oil and six white gift bags. That's a lot of olive oil to give at once, but whether it's too many depends on who you're gifting and how you plan to use it.
If you're looking for a single hostess gift, six bottles might feel like overkill. But if you need gifts for multiple people, or you want to keep a few bottles for yourself while sharing the rest, the set starts to make sense.
What the catalog confirms about the set
- Everyday EVOO Gifting Set (6 Bottles): The Everyday EVOO Gifting Set includes six bottles of Everyday Extra Virgin Olive Oil and six chic white gift bags. The six bags mean each bottle can stand alone as its own gift, so you're not locked into giving all six to one person.

Everyday EVOO Gifting Set (6 Bottles) - Everyday EVOO Gifting Set (6 Bottles): The catalog describes EVOO as a perfect host gift, a thoughtful thank you gift, and a welcome change from gifting wine. This positions the set as a versatile gift option, but the quantity still matters: six bottles is a different commitment than one.
When six bottles are not too many
The set earns its keep when you have a list of people to thank. With six individual gift bags, you can split the bottles and give one to each host, colleague, or family member. That turns one purchase into six thoughtful gifts.
It also works well if you entertain often. Keeping a bottle in the pantry for cooking and another on the counter for finishing means you'll go through olive oil faster than you think. The set gives you a ready supply without a trip to the store.
If you're gifting to a couple or a household that cooks regularly, six bottles might be seen as a generous pantry staple rather than excess. Some recipients will appreciate not having to buy olive oil for months.
When six bottles might be too many
For a single host gift, six bottles can feel heavy and awkward to carry, especially if you're also bringing wine or dessert. A single bottle or a smaller set might be more appropriate.
If you don't know the recipient's cooking habits, six bottles could be more than they need. Olive oil is perishable and best used within a reasonable time, so giving a large quantity to someone who rarely cooks might not be ideal.
Budget is another consideration. The catalog price for the set is $72.50, with a comparison price of $145.00. That's a meaningful investment compared to a single bottle, so you want to be confident the recipient will use it.
Six bottles vs. fewer: a quick decision guide
Here's a simple way to think about the quantity decision:
- You need multiple gifts: Six bottles with six bags means you can give one to each of several people. This is the set's strongest use case.
- You cook with olive oil regularly: Keeping a supply on hand for cooking and finishing means six bottles will be used, not stored.
- You're attending one dinner party: A single bottle or a smaller set is easier to carry and less likely to overwhelm the host.
- You're on a tight gift budget: The set costs more than a single bottle, so if you're unsure about the recipient's needs, a smaller option is safer.
What the catalog doesn't tell you
The catalog doesn't specify the bottle size, so we can't confirm the total volume of olive oil in the set. It also doesn't provide shelf life or storage instructions, so if you're planning to keep bottles for a long time, you'll want to check the label or contact the store.
What we do know is that the set includes six bottles and six gift bags, and the catalog positions EVOO as a gift-friendly product. Use that as your starting point, and let the recipient's habits guide your final call.

